|Year : 2018 | Volume
| Issue : 1 | Page : 42-46
Cryotherapy of cutaneous leishmaniasis caused by Leishmania major in BALB/c mice: A comparative experimental study
Minoo Shaddel1, Iraj Sharifi2, Mehran Karvar3, Alireza Keyhani2, Zahra Baziar2
1 Department of Medical Parasitology and Mycology, School of Medicine, AJA University of Medical Sciences, Tehran; Kerman Leishmaniasis Research Center, Kerman University of Medical Sciences, Kerman, Iran
2 Kerman Leishmaniasis Research Center, Kerman University of Medical Sciences, Kerman, Iran
3 Department of Medical Parasitology and Mycology, School of Medicine, AJA University of Medical Sciences, Tehran, Iran
|Date of Submission||20-Nov-2017|
|Date of Acceptance||29-Dec-2017|
|Date of Web Publication||18-Jun-2018|
Kerman University of Medical Sciences, Emam High Way, Kerman 7616914115
Source of Support: None, Conflict of Interest: None
Background & objectives: Leishmania parasites are sensitive to very low temperature. Cryotherapy is considered as an alternative to the existing pentavalent antimonials, for local treatment of cutaneous leishmaniasis (CL). Normally, liquid nitrogen (N2) at a temperature of -196 °C, is used in cryotherapy of CL, but it’s efficacy is not consistent. Recently, few studies have also reported the use of carbon dioxide (CO2) slush at -78.5 °C in CL cryotherapy. This study was aimed to evaluate the effectiveness of N2 vs CO2 cryotherapy for CL treatment in mice.
Methods: In total, 21 BALB/c mice were infected with Leishmania major strain [MRHO/IR/74/ER]. Samples were divided into three groups based on the intervention provided—Solid CO2 cryotherapy, liquid N2 cryotherapy and control group; with seven mice randomly assigned to each group. Control group received no intervention, and in the other two groups cryotherapy was used every two weeks for maximum of three months. Follow up examinations were scheduled at the time of cryotherapy, during which the size of each lesion was measured. For three mice in each study group, the spleen parasite DNA load was quantified using real-time PCR.
Results: After treatment, the liquid N2 cryotherapy showed significant reduction in size of the lesions (p = 0.029) as compared to the solid CO2 cryotherapy and control group. Also, Leishmania DNA load in spleen was significantly lower in the mice receiving liquid N2 cryotherapy (p <0.001).
Interpretation & conclusion: Liquid N2 cryotherapy is superior to CO2 cryotherapy, and it can be an effective method for controlling L. major infection. Further investigations are essential to find optimal number of treatment sessions and time intervals.
Keywords: Cryotherapy; cutaneous leishmaniasis; Leishmania major; liquid nitrogen; solid carbon dioxide
|How to cite this article:|
Shaddel M, Sharifi I, Karvar M, Keyhani A, Baziar Z. Cryotherapy of cutaneous leishmaniasis caused by Leishmania major in BALB/c mice: A comparative experimental study. J Vector Borne Dis 2018;55:42-6
|How to cite this URL:|
Shaddel M, Sharifi I, Karvar M, Keyhani A, Baziar Z. Cryotherapy of cutaneous leishmaniasis caused by Leishmania major in BALB/c mice: A comparative experimental study. J Vector Borne Dis [serial online] 2018 [cited 2019 Nov 11];55:42-6. Available from: http://www.jvbd.org/text.asp?2018/55/1/42/234625
| Introduction|| |
Leishmaniasis is a parasitic disease caused by various species of Leishmania protozoan. The parasite is transmitted to humans through the bite of an infected sandfly. In recent years, the prevalence and geographical distribution of the disease have increased and expanded to new regions of the world,. Furthermore, due to high immigration, international travel and military operations in endemic areas, leishmaniasis has received more attention in developed countries,,. It is a serious health problem in the Middle East, particularly Iran.
Although, some promising attempts have been done to develop a vaccine,,, treatment is still the cornerstone modality for controlling leishmaniasis infection. The first-line treatment for cutaneous leishmaniasis (CL) include intramuscular or intralesional injection of pentavalent antimonial compounds particularly Glucantime®,. However, due to long duration of use, several side-effects, low efficacy and increasing resistance to these drugs, tremendous efforts have been made in order to develop alternative systemic or topical treatments,,.
Given the sensitivity of Leishmania parasites to freezing, cryotherapy is now used as an adjuvant therapy along with antimonial compounds and sometimes used alone as an alternative treatment to cure CL, in certain regions such as Iran, Yemen, and Jordan,,,,,,,,.
Normally, liquid nitrogen (N2) at a temperature of –196 °C is used in cryotherapy of cutaneous lesions. This therapy has been reported to be successful in >95% of cases, however, in some controlled trials, its efficacy was as low as 27%,,,,. The ambiguity in results have caused controversy about the efficacy of cryotherapy on CL. Recently, a study showed that cryotherapy with CO2 slush (dry ice) at -78.5 °C was effective in treating CL in Yemen. The effectiveness of the two types of cryotherapy regimens (one with liquid N2 and another with solid CO2) have not been studied and compared in any published study.
Liquid nitrogen, compared to dry ice, is not easily available and requires higher cost of maintenance. This study was aimed to evaluate the effectiveness of liquid N2 cryotherapy, and compare its efficacy with the solid CO2 cryotherapy in the treatment of CL. To investigate the effect of cryotherapy in two different temperature ranges (–196 and –78.5 °C) in treating CL, a standard animal model of the disease was used.
| Material & Methods|| |
The study was conducted in the Kerman Leishmaniasis Research Center, Kerman University of Medical Sciences, Kerman, Iran during summer and fall of 2015.
Study sample and design
Pasteur Institute of Iran, Tehran provided male BALB/c mice (6–8 wk old and weighing approximately 20 to 22 g) for the study. Given the heterogeneity of mice and the similarity of their maintenance conditions, 21 mice were included in the study; and divided into three groups (of seven mice each), namely control, cryotherapy with solid CO2, and cryotherapy with liquid N2. This study was conducted as an experimental controlled animal trial.
The animal care and the experimental protocols were in accordance with the Ministry of Health and Education of Iran animal care guidelines. The study procedures were approved by the Ethics Committee, AJA University of Medical Sciences, Tehran, Iran (the assigned ethical code is IR.AJAUMS.REC.1396.109). Mice in all the three groups were maintained in similar settings in terms of storage conditions, ambient temperature, drinking water, food and light–dark cycle. At the end of the experiments, all mice were buried according to standard protocols to prevent the spread of the infection.
Cultivation of L. major and infection of mice
The required parasites for inoculation in mice were cultured in a suitable environment in the Kerman Leishmaniasis Research Center, Kerman, Iran. Leishmania major strain (MRHO/IR/74/ER) used in this study, was kindly provided by Prof. A. Khamesipour (Center for Research and Training in Skin Diseases and Leprosy, Tehran University of Medical Sciences, Tehran, Iran). The isolation and mass production of the parasites were carried out via culturing them in Novy-MacNeal-Nicolle medium (NNN) and then sub-culturing in RPMI 1640 medium (Biosera, France) supplemented with 10% fetal bovine serum (Sigma-Aldrich, USA), 2 mM L-glutamine (Gibco BRL), 100 IU/ml penicillin and 100 μg/ml streptomycin (Sigma, Germany) followed by incubation at 25 °C.
Before inoculation, the base of 30 mice tails was shaved by scalpel and was disinfected by 70% ethanol.
Then 0.1 ml of suspension containing 2.5 χ 106 L. major (MRHO/IR/74/ER) promastigotes in stationary stage was injected subcutaneously at the base of the tails by using insulin syringe. Till the appearance of CL lesions, the mice were kept in cages for six weeks. When they developed cutaneous lesions, 21 of them were selected for the study. Remaining infected mice were killed and buried as per standard protocols.
Study arms, intervention, and follow-up protocol
The 21 infected mice were randomly divided into three groups and a number was assigned to each mouse. The clinical status and size of the induration were recorded in a structured form.
In the control group, the mice were maintained in their settings without any intervention. In cryotherapy with solid CO2 group, dry ice pellet, based on the lesion size, was placed on the lesion (including a margin of 2 mm on the healthy skin) with gentle pressure for 1 min in order to freeze the lesion completely (with a margin of 2 mm of healthy skin). In cryotherapy with liquid N2 group, liquid N2 was placed on the lesion using a swab (including 2 mm margin out of the lesion on the healthy skin), with gentle pressure for 20 sec to freeze the lesion.
The follow-up examinations were scheduled every two weeks for maximum of three months. At the follow-up visits, the lesions of all three groups were evaluated and if a lesion was found active (presence of induration), another session of the corresponding therapy was applied to the lesion. The treatment sessions were continued for maximum of three months or until the lesions were cured, whichever was earlier. At the time of follow-up, longitudinal and transverse lesion diameters were measured by using a Vernier caliper, and the size of the lesion was calculated by dividing the total by two, as described earlier by Sokal.
At the end of the three-months period, all of the mice were killed painlessly. Three mice from each group (total nine) were randomly selected and their spleens were aseptically removed for DNA extraction. In this study, we developed and validated a SYBR green based real-time PCR in order to detect and quantify L. major parasite load with high sensitivity in spleen biopsy specimens.
DNA extraction and real-time PCR
Genomic DNA was extracted from 10 mg of spleen tissue with TIANamp Genomic DNA kit (Tiangen Biotech, China) according to the manufacturer’s protocol.
Reaction was performed using 200 ng of the DNA, 5 pmol of RV1 (Forward: 5’-CTTTTCTGGTCCCGC- GGGTAGG-3’) and RV2 (Reverse: 5’-CCACCTG-GCCTATTTTACACCA-3’) primers (which were used to amplify a 140 bp conserved region of the Leishmania kinetoplast DNA minicircle as described by Lachaud et al), and 5 μl SYBR Green Master mix (Takara Bio Inc, Japan) in a total volume of 12 μl with the following amplification program: 95 °C for 5 min, and then 40 cycles at 95 °C for 10 sec, 60 °C for 20 sec, and 72 °C for 20 sec. After PCR amplification, a melting curve was generated to check the amplicon specificity; consisting one cycle at 95–72°C. Reactions were run in Rotor Gene Q real time system (Qiagen, Germany).
The DNA of a normal mouse skin from the base of the tail and wild-type L. major DNA were used as negative and positive controls, respectively. For drawing the standard curve, the genomic DNA of L. major was used in dilution series 0.1–105 /ml parasites. All tests were performed in duplicate.
One-way ANOVA was used to compare the size variables of the lesion and spleen parasite load in the three groups. Paired t-test was used to compare lesion size at the beginning and the end of treatment in each group. Graph- Pad Prism software version 7 was used for data analysis. The p-value ≤ 0.05 was considered significant.
| Results|| |
The mean sizes of the lesion’s induration at the beginning and end of the treatment in the three groups are presented in [Table 1]. The ANOVA test, revealed that the mean size of induration of the lesions pre-treatment was not significantly different in the three groups. However, after the treatment, the mean size in the liquid N2 group was significantly smaller than the other two groups (p = 0.013 as compared to control and p = 0.046 as compared to solid CO2 group). No significant difference was observed in the mean size of lesions at the end of follow ups between the control and cryotherapy with solid CO2 group.The paired t-test showed that the lesion’s size in mice receiving liquid N2 cryotherapy significantly decreased after the treatment (p=0.029), though this was not significant for the control and solid CO2 group. [Figure 1] illustrates the mean spleen parasite DNA load in the study group. The comparison of the mean parasite load in the three groups by one-way ANOVA showed that the spleen parasite load in liquid N2 was significantly lesser than the other two groups (p <0.001). However, this value was not significantly different between the solid CO2 and control group. Few side effects such as erythema and swelling were seen in both the intervention methods.
|Table 1: Mean size of indurations in the study group at the beginning and the end of three months' treatment|
Click here to view
|Figure 1: Log of the mean parasites load in spleen specimens according to the study groups. A significant difference was observed in parasite load between the liquid N2 group and the other two groups (p<0.001).|
Click here to view
| Discussion|| |
So far, there is no comprehensive consensus on CL treatment method, dose and duration of therapy. Since half century, the first-line treatment of leishmaniasis has been pentavalent antimonial compounds. However, due to the significant side-effects, low efficacy, painful injections and the emergence of drug resistant parasites, many attempts have been carried out to find an effective adjuvant therapy or alternative regimen. Finding an alternative cure for CL is still a big challenge for countries where the disease is endemic,,,,.
Leishmania parasite is sensitive to freezing as very low temperature causes the parasites to break apart in the connective tissue of the dermis. Even, cryotherapy can cause tissue damage, rupture of the membranes of macrophages, and release of Leishman-Donovan bodies within the tissue, along with the possibility of increase in antigen presentation to the immune system,.
Considering the sensitivity of Leishmania parasites to freezing, cryotherapy is practiced in some regions, such as Sri Lanka, Jordan, Turkey, Yemen and notably in Iran as adjunctive therapy along with pentavalent antimonial compounds, and even sometimes as replacement therapy in the treatment of CL.
Different studies with various findings have reported the efficacy of cryotherapy with liquid N2. The degree of effectiveness in these studies varied between 27 to 100%,,,. Factors such as different species, location and size of lesions, demographic changes (population variations), cryotherapy regimen, frequency, accuracy, and study type could be the possible reasons for such differences in the efficacy of the therapy. This study aimed to evaluate the effectiveness of cryotherapy in treating CL by using liquid N2; and compared it with the effectiveness of solid CO2 in BALB/c mice, all of which were infected with a similar parasite species in similar site of their body (tail). This was in order to minimize the impact of population variations and different locations of the lesions on treatment results.
With respect to lesion size, the results showed that the effectiveness of cryotherapy with liquid N2 was significantly higher than the effectiveness of cryotherapy with dry ice. On molecular level, liquid N2 group had significantly less spleen parasite load as compared to the control group. This also confirmed the desirable effect of liquid N2 cryotherapy for control of Leishmania infection. At the end of the treatment, parasite load and size of lesions in dry ice cryotherapy group did not show any significant difference in comparison to the control group.
Several studies have evaluated the efficacy of cryotherapy in treatment of CL. In Turkey, Gurei et al reported that the efficacy of liquid N2 cryotherapy in the treatment of CL was 78%, following three-month treatment period. Asilian et al have reported response rate of 57.3% for cryotherapy. Recently, Mosleh et al? found that the effectiveness of cryotherapy with liquid N2 spray, for one to four sessions in 120 patients consisting 375 CL lesions caused by L. major was 84%; the remaining lesions (16%) were cured after an additional one to three session(s). In a controlled trial carried out by Al-Gindan et al in Saudi Arabia, on 600 patients with CL, 27% ef- ficacy was reported for N2 cryotherapy as compared to 41% with Sb and 30% with ketoconazole.
Despite the differences listed in the above studies, the majority of researches demonstrated that the efficacy of liquid N2 cryotherapy in the treatment of CL was significant. The results of this study also indicated a favourable impact of liquid N2 cryotherapy to control the parasitic load of L. major in the host body.
Cryotherapy may cause bulla and pain at the site of its application which would last for several days. Hence, there should be a time interval between the treatment sessions in order to minimize the side effects. Different treatment intervals of cryotherapy have been used for treating CL. Studies have used single dose, weekly,, or once every two weeks, regimens. These studies have applied different number of treatment sessions, for example one, two,, or more,. The number of treatment sessions is usually based on the clinical response. The researchers may use the guidelines of their country or they may decide about the duration of treatment based upon their own clinical experience. In the present study, according to the national protocol, cryotherapy was performed once every two weeks for maximum of three months., However, further studies with large sample sizes are needed to determine the appropriate time interval and duration of CL treatment with cryotherapy, to obtain higher efficacy in future.
Few studies have focused on the effectiveness of solid CO2 . Al-Qubati et al reported that cryotherapy with CO2 slush with a temperature of –78.5 °C was effective in the treatment of CL. However, considering the limitations of their study, they stated that additional randomized clinical trials are needed to further analyze the efficacy of CO2 slush in CL therapy. In a non-controlled study on 30 patients with CL in Egypt, Bassiouny et al reported that the efficacy of cryosurgery with CO2 cryomachine in the treatment of CL was 100%. Studies comparing the effectiveness of the two methods of cryotherapy with liquid N2 and solid CO2 are not available in literature. In addition, there is no any study on the effectiveness of cryotherapy in treatment of CL using molecular diagnostic assays either.
With respect to the effectiveness of cryotherapy with solid CO2 at a temperature of –78.5 °C, the findings of this study are not consistent with the results reported by Al-Qubati et al and Bassiouny et al. This could be due to differences in the species causing infection, the study design, lack of control group etc. Further, studies are suggested targeting efficacy of this method with more frequent treatment sessions (e.g. once every week).
The results of the present study showed that use of liquid N2 for cryotherapy is more effective than solid CO2 in treatment of CL.
Limitations of the study
It has been demonstrated that in an experimental group not all animals achieve the same levels of infection. Therefore, it is suggested that further studies with larger sample size should be designed in which the levels of parasitaemia pre-treatment can be determined.
| Conclusion|| |
N2 cryotherapy showed better results than CO2 cryotherapy. Since cryotherapy is a topical treatment modality and is well tolerated due to its few side-effects, it could be an effective method for controlling Leishmania major infection. Further clinical trials using larger sample size in volunteer humans is essential for future CL treatment policies.
Conflict of interest
The funder had no financial or proprietary interest in any material or method used in this study and had no role in study design, data collection and analysis, or preparation of the manuscript. The authors declare that there is no conflict of interests.
| Acknowledgements|| |
The authors appreciate the close association and support of the Kerman Leishmaniasis Research Center and Kerman University of Medical Sciences, Kerman, Iran. This study was supported and funded by the Vice-Chancellor for Research, Artesh Jomhouri-eslami Iran (AJA) University of Medical Sciences, Tehran, Iran (Grant No. 14177755 B.N. —in Persian).
| References|| |
Goto H, Lindoso JA. Current diagnosis and treatment of cutaneous and mucocutaneous leishmaniasis. Expert Rev Anti Infect Ther
2010; 8(4): 419-33.
Control of the leishmaniases: Report of a meeting of the WHO expert committee on the control of leishmaniases, March 22-26, 2010
. WHO Tech Rep Ser No. 949. Geneva: World Health Organization 2010. Available from: http://whqlibdoc.who.int/trs/WHO_TRS_949_eng.pdf (Accessed on November 16, 2017)
Weina PJ, Neafie RC, Wortmann G, Polhemus M, Aronson NE. Old world leishmaniasis: An emerging infection among deployed US military and civilian workers. Clin Infect Dis
2004; 39(11): 1674-80.
Willard RJ, Jeffcoat AM, Benson PM, Walsh DS. Cutaneous leishmaniasis in soldiers from Fort Campbell, Kentucky returning from Operation Iraqi Freedom highlights diagnostic and therapeutic options. J Am Acad Dermatol
Zapor MJ, Moran KA. Infectious diseases during wartime. Curr Opin Infect Dis
Shirzadi MR, Mohebali M, Yaghoubi Ershadi MR. Principles of cutaneous leishmaniasis prevention and surveillance, v 1. I edn. Tehran: Department of Zoonotic Diseases, Center for Contagious Diseases Management, Ministry of Health and Medical Education (Islamic Republic of Iran) 2011; p. 67-77 (in Persian).
Gillespie PM, Beaumier CM, Strych U, Hayward T, Hotez PJ, Bottazzi ME. Status of vaccine research and development of vaccines for leishmaniasis. Vaccine
2016; 54(26): 2992-5.
Campbell K, Diao H, Jiaxiang J, Soong L. DNA immunization with the gene encoding P4 nuclease of Leishmaina amazonensis
protects mice against cutaneous leishmaniasis. Infect Immun
2003; 71(11): 6270-8.
Shaddel M, Oormazdi H, Akhlaghi L, Kazemi B, Bandehpour M. Cloning of Leishmania major P4
gene. Cell J (Yahkhteh)
2008; 10(3): 201-4.
Masmoudi A, Hariz W, Marrekchi S, Amouri M, Turki H. Old World cutaneous leishmaniasis: Diagnosis and treatment. J Dermatol Case Rep
2013; 7(2): 31-41.
Alavi-Naini R, Fazaeli A, O’Dempsey T. Topical treatment modalities for old world cutaneous leishmaniasis: A review. Prague Med Rep
Daie Parizi MH, Karvar M, Sharifi I, Bahrampour A, Heshmat Khah A, Rahnama Z, et al
. The topical treatment of anthroponotic cutaneous leishmaniasis with the tincture of thioxolone plus benzoxonium chloride (Thio-Ben) along with cryotherapy: A single-blind randomized clinical trial. Dermatol Ther
2015; 28(3): 140-6.
Gurei MS, Tatli N, Ozbilge H, Erel O, Seyrek A, Kocyigit A, et al
. Efficacy of cryotherapy and intralesional pentostam in treatment of cutaneous leishmaniasis. J Egypt Soc Parasitol
2000; 30(1): 169-76.
Leibovici V, Aram H. Cryotherapy in acute cutaneous leishmaniasis. Int J Dermatol
1986; 25(7): 473-5.
Asilian A, Sadeghinia A, Faghihi G, Momeni A. Comparative study of the efficacy of combined cryotherapy and intralesional meglumine antimoniate (Glucantime) vs
cryotherapy and intralesional meglumine antimoniate (Glucantime) alone for the treatment of cutaneous leishmaniasis. Int J Dermatol
2004; 43(4): 281-3.
Mosleh IM, Geith E, Natsheh L, Schönian G, Abotteen N, Kharabsheh S. Efficacy of a weekly cryotherapy regimen to treat Leishmania major
cutaneous leishmaniasis. J Am Acad Dermatol
2008; 58(4): 617-24.
Al-Gindan Y, Kubba R, Omer AH, el-Hassan AM. Cryosurgery in Old World cutaneous leishmaniasis. Br J Dermatol
Al-Qubati Y, Janniger EJ, Schwartz RA. Old World cutaneous leishmaniasis: Cryosurgery using carbon dioxide slush in a resource-poor country. Int J Dermatol
Sokal JE. Measurement of delayed skin-test responses. N Eng J Med
Lachaud L, Machergui Hammami S, Chabbert E, Dereure J, Dedet JP, Bastien P. Comparison of six PCR methods using peripheral blood for the detection of canine visceral leishmaniasis. J Clin Microbiol
2002; 40(1): 210-5.
Bassiouny A, El Meshad M, Talaat M, Kutty K, Meta B. Cryosurgery in cutaneous leishmaniasis. Br J Dermatol
1982; 107(4): 467-74.